Demystifying Cybersecurity Insurance Requirements

How to Navigate Coverage

If you own a business or have a stake in one, you know surprises are typically not the fun kind. Cybersecurity insurance requirements exist to provide financial protections in the event of unexpected cyber incidents and unplanned disruptions to business.

It can be difficult to navigate cyber insurance and understand what coverage you really need. No business is mandated to have cybersecurity insurance, so having a complete understanding of your risk tolerance is important.

In this article, we’ll explain how you can best navigate cybersecurity insurance requirements for your business and understand what you really need.


Does Your Business Need Cybersecurity Insurance?

I recommend cyber insurance because, put simply, having it is better than not having it. Even businesses with robust cybersecurity programs can fall victim to cyber attacks that have the potential to disrupt or cripple operations.  

However, like personal insurance, it can be hard to decide whether it’s worth it to invest in certain coverage options. Insurance only pays off when you need to use it, and it can be easy to operate under a mindset that you won’t. So while I advocate for cyber insurance, business leaders should only invest in the levels of coverage that make sense for them.

Here are a few criteria to help guide cybersecurity insurance requirements:

1. Business Size and Resources

Small businesses in particular typically have more limited personnel and financial resources, and if managing a cybersecurity program in-house is challenging, cyber insurance and the premiums that come with it likely will be as well. Additionally, smaller businesses may prefer to invest in growth rather than on security and insurance. Cyber protections are important, and small and medium businesses should invest in their cybersecurity programs – such as shaping an incident response and recovery plan – before focusing on insurance as their threat risk is typically lower than in larger corporations.  

2. Regulatory Requirements

As mentioned, no industry is mandated to have cybersecurity insurance, but some more highly regulated industries like healthcare and financial services may need cyber insurance in order to meet certain regulatory requirements. In these cases, your cyber insurance plan should satisfy those compliance requirements, and whether your business invests in additional coverage is up to you. 

3. Vendor Risk Level 

Your business may outsource different services to third-party vendors, and if those vendors have cyber insurance, your business likely would be covered as well. However, third-party vendor relationships create security risks to your business as well, so even if your vendor is covered, it may not be enough to help your business in the event of an attack. Review your vendor contracts and understand exactly what you would get under their coverage and what would happen if an attacker used their access to breach your network.

4. Overall Risk

Businesses that have decided to purchase cyber insurance do so because they have determined their risk profile requires it. Before making a decision about cyber insurance, conduct a risk assessment to understand your security posture and gain a complete picture of the financial impacts your business could face following a breach.

Despite these criteria, there are still some organizations that should have cybersecurity insurance and either don’t have it or don’t have enough. Look at what your business could realistically lose in a ransomware or other attack and you’ll most likely find that investing in cyber insurance is the more financially sound option.


cover and spread for the Rising Vulnerabilities Guide

PROTECT YOUR ORGANIZATION AGAINST RISING VULNERABILITIES

What Type of Cyber Insurance Do I Need?

If you’ve assessed the cost differential and decided to pursue a cyber insurance policy, the next step may seem even more complex – deciding what type of coverage to get, and how much.

You can leverage an insurance broker who will select the right coverage based on your company, risk levels, and budget. Similarly, if you work with an MSSP, many have cyber insurance and your company can benefit from that coverage as a result. 

Here is a breakdown of coverage options to help guide your decision-making process. 

First-Party Coverage

This option covers the direct costs to your company in the event of a cyber incident.

  • Data Breach Response
    Covers the cost of notifying affected individuals, providing credit monitoring, and conducting forensic investigations.
  • Business Interruption
    Reimburses lost income and extra expenses if operations are disrupted due to a cyberattack or system failure.
  • Data Restoration
    Pays for recovering, replacing, or recreating lost or corrupted data.
  • Cyber Extortion (Ransomware)
    Covers ransom payments, negotiation costs, and incident response support.
  • Digital Asset Loss
    Applies to loss or damage to software, systems, or proprietary digital assets.

 

Third-Party Liability Coverage

This type of coverage protects your business from lawsuits or claims filed by others affected by the breach.

  • Network Security Liability
    Covers legal expenses if a company fails to prevent a cyber incident that affects customers, partners, or vendors.
  • Privacy Liability
    Covers liabilities stemming from the unauthorized disclosure or misuse of personal or sensitive data.
  • Regulatory Defense and Penalties
    Helps cover legal defense and fines related to violations of data protection laws (like GDPR or HIPAA, if applicable).
  • Media Liability
    Covers issues like copyright infringement, defamation, or privacy violations stemming from online content.

 

Optional or Specialized Coverages

These types of coverages are becoming increasingly important depending on industry and risk profile.

  • Social Engineering Fraud
    Covers financial losses from scams like phishing or CEO fraud that trick employees into transferring money or sensitive data.
  • Reputation Management/Public Relations
    Helps cover the cost of crisis communications and brand damage control.
  • Vendor or Supply Chain Disruption
    Covers losses resulting from attacks on third-party providers or vendors.
  • Bricking Coverage
    Pays for hardware rendered unusable by malware (especially relevant in OT environments or IoT-heavy industries).

Having strong cybersecurity controls in place—like EDR, MFA, network monitoring, and employee training—can reduce premiums and increase the chance of a successful claim. 

Some insurers require minimum controls before they’ll issue coverage; you can expect lower rates if you have a strong cybersecurity program since your incidents are likely to go down, and higher rates if you have very few controls in place since your incident rates are likely to be higher.

Team of people trying to figure out insurance

The Cybersecurity Mindset Shift 

If your company is considering cyber insurance, you may have already experienced how this process drives a mindset shift about cybersecurity.

Insurance providers know cyber attacks are a “when” and not “if” scenario, and that insurance is simply adding another layer of protection. What an insurance company is looking for is proof that your company is being proactive in preventing cyber attacks and is having regular conversations about your company’s risks.

You should be  prepared to face realities about how secure your company really is; for example, maybe your company was breached in the past but no additional cybersecurity protections were put in place. Or maybe you have cybersecurity protections in place but they’re not as effective as they need to be. 

If company leadership wants to purchase only the bare minimum of coverage, it will become clear very quickly based on information your company has provided that another level of coverage is needed. Only a mindset shift about your actual insurance needs will result in the right amount of coverage – and make the investment worth it in the long run.

Stay Updated with Cybersecurity Insights

Cybersecurity Insurance Is for Everyone

Cybersecurity insurance requirements or the need for coverage aren’t relegated to specific industries. Any organization that could stand to lose enough money in a cyber attack that would put them out of business should look into having cyber insurance.

There is a lot to lose in a cyber attack: lawsuits over mishandling of private data, loss of revenue, and potential reputational damage. Cybersecurity insurance is another tool in the toolbox to add protection in an environment that is constantly threatened by cyber attacks.

Cyber insurance is one way to maximize your cybersecurity spend outside of staffing or additional third-party security solutions. Understanding your real vulnerabilities to attack and leveraging different ways of managing them is a sound approach to true cybersecurity protection.

Talk to us about a managed security solution to help you navigate your cybersecurity insurance needs and requirements. An MSSP can provide expert guidance on even the most complex aspects of your cybersecurity program.